8 Best Rums for Pina Colada in 2024

When it comes to making the perfect Pina Colada, the type of white rum you choose can make all the difference. We've scoured the market to find the best white rums that will take your Pina Colada to the next level. Our selection of rums is not only delicious on their own but also blends perfectly with other ingredients to create a refreshing and tropical cocktail. Here are our top picks for the best white rums for Pina Colada.

If you want to know what Rum is - make sure to read our thorough Rum guide

Pina Colada Mocktail Cocktail

Plantation Rum - Three Stars White Rum

If you are looking for a white rum that is perfect for mixing delicious cocktails, we highly recommend Plantation White Three Stars. This rum is a blend of the best rums from the Caribbean, including a 3-year-old carbon-filtered rum from Trinidad, a rum from Barbados, and two rums from Jamaica.

Pros

• This rum has a complex and balanced flavor profile that includes subtle spicy and floral notes, as well as hints of tropical fruits, brown sugar, and ripe bananas.
• Plantation White Three Stars is an excellent choice for mixing cocktails, as it adds a depth of flavor that simple rum cannot achieve.
• This rum has won several awards, including Gold Medals at the International Rum Conference and the RUMX.P, as well as the Rum Festival in Miami.

Cons

• This rum is on the pricier side compared to other white rums on the market.
• Some drinkers may find the flavor profile too complex for their tastes.
• Plantation White Three Stars may not be the best choice for those who prefer a simpler, more straightforward rum flavor.

Plantation White Three Stars is an excellent choice for those who are looking to elevate their cocktail game. This rum's complex flavor profile adds a depth of flavor to classic cocktails like the Daiquiri, Mojito, and Cuba Libre, making them more interesting and enjoyable.

If you are specifically looking for the best white rum for a Pina Colada, Plantation White Three Stars is a great choice. The rum's complex flavor profile pairs perfectly with the sweetness of pineapple and coconut, creating a delicious and refreshing cocktail that is sure to impress. Plus, the rum's subtle spicy and floral notes add a unique twist to the classic Pina Colada flavor.

Check Price

Mango Piña Colada Cocktail

Captain Morgan White Rum

If you're looking for a versatile white rum to use as a base for your cocktails, we recommend Captain Morgan White.

Pros

• The blend of Caribbean rums gives it a refreshing and light taste
• The smooth, medium-bodied flavor with a slightly sweet note makes it perfect for mixing
• The rum is easy to find and available at a reasonable price point

Cons

• The flavor may be too mild for those looking for a more intense rum taste
• Some drinkers may prefer a more complex flavor profile
• The plastic screw cap may not be as durable as a cork or metal cap

Captain Morgan White is a great choice for making a classic Pina Colada. The smooth, slightly sweet flavor of the rum blends well with the pineapple and coconut flavors to create a refreshing tropical drink. We recommend using fresh pineapple juice and coconut cream for the best taste. Add ice and blend until smooth, then garnish with a slice of pineapple and a cherry.

Overall, Captain Morgan White is a versatile and affordable option for mixing cocktails. Its mild flavor profile makes it a great choice for those who prefer a smoother taste. Whether you're making a simple rum and coke or a more complex cocktail, Captain Morgan White is a reliable choice that won't break the bank.

Check Price

Coconut Cream Piña Colada Cocktail

Bacardi BACARD Superior White Rum

If you're looking for the perfect white rum for your Pina Colada, BACARDÍ Carta Blanca Rum is a great choice. It has a clean, dry finish with notes of roasted vanilla and citrus, making it the perfect complement to the sweet pineapple and coconut flavors in the cocktail.

Pros

• Legendary white rum from the Caribbean, perfect for mixing in cocktails like the Daiquiri, Mojito, and Pina Colada
• Made from sustainably sourced ingredients and Bonsucro®-certified sugar cane, ensuring high quality and sustainability
• Filtered through a secret charcoal blend, giving it a perfectly balanced character that doesn't overpower other flavors in a cocktail

Cons

• Some may find the taste too clean and dry for sipping on its own
• Price may be higher than other white rums on the market
• Some may prefer a white rum with more complex flavors for mixing in cocktails

BACARDÍ Carta Blanca Rum has a long history of being the go-to white rum for bartenders around the world. Its clean, dry finish and balanced character make it the perfect base for a variety of cocktails, including the classic Pina Colada. We love how it brings out the sweet, tropical flavors of the cocktail without overpowering them with too much rum flavor.

One thing to keep in mind is that BACARDÍ Carta Blanca Rum may not be the best choice for those who prefer sipping on their rum neat or on the rocks. While it has a pleasant flavor, it may not be complex enough to stand on its own. However, for mixing in cocktails, it's hard to beat the quality and consistency of BACARDÍ Carta Blanca Rum.

Overall, we highly recommend BACARDÍ Carta Blanca Rum for anyone looking for a high-quality white rum to use in their favorite cocktails, especially the Pina Colada. Its sustainably sourced ingredients and long history of quality and innovation make it a great choice for any home bartender or cocktail enthusiast.

Check Price

Green Tea Piña Colada Cocktail

Tiki Lovers White Rum

If you're looking for a white rum that can add a unique flavor to your cocktails, then Tiki Lovers White Rum is a great option to consider.

Pros

• This blend of Jamaican and Trinidadian rums creates a fruity, exotic, and fresh flavor, making it a perfect fit for tropical cocktails like Pina Colada.
• The rum is aged for 2-3 years in small oak barrels, which gives it a unique character and makes it smoother than other white rums.
• The 50% alcohol content of the rum makes it perfect for creating strong and flavorful cocktails.

Cons

• The rum may be too sweet for some people's taste, especially if you prefer drier cocktails.
• The price of the rum is slightly higher compared to other white rums in the market.
• The rum may not be suitable for people with diabetes due to its sugar content.

Tiki Lovers White Rum is an excellent choice for making Pina Colada. The fruity and floral notes of the rum complement the pineapple and coconut flavors of the cocktail, creating a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. The rum's smoothness and high alcohol content also make it ideal for creating a strong and flavorful cocktail that can be enjoyed both on a hot summer day or a cold winter night.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a white rum that can add a unique flavor to your cocktails, Tiki Lovers White Rum is a great option to consider. Its fruity and exotic flavor, smoothness, and high alcohol content make it a perfect fit for tropical cocktails like Pina Colada.

Check Price

Chocolate Piña Colada Cocktail

Banks 5 Island Blend Premium White Rum

If you want a premium white rum that can make your cocktails stand out, Banks 5 Island Blend Premium White Rum is worth considering.

Pros

• This blend of 20 different rums from 8 distilleries in 5 countries creates a unique flavor profile that can elevate any cocktail.
• The aroma is complex, with notes of cinnamon, vanilla, dark chocolate, basil, habanero, and green apple, among others.
• The Batavia Arrack from Java, which is aged in teak casks, adds an oriental twist to the blend and helps tie the different rums together.

Cons

• This is a premium rum, so it's more expensive than some other options on the market.
• Some drinkers may find the flavor too complex or overpowering for their tastes.
• It may not be the best choice for those who prefer a more traditional, straightforward white rum flavor.

Banks 5 Island Blend is a versatile and complex rum that can add depth and flavor to any cocktail. We particularly recommend it for Pina Colada, as the blend's unique flavor profile can enhance the tropical notes in the drink. The cinnamon, vanilla, and dark chocolate notes in the rum can add warmth and richness to the Pina Colada, while the green apple and habanero notes can provide a subtle, spicy kick. Overall, if you're looking for a premium white rum that can take your cocktails to the next level, Banks 5 Island Blend is definitely worth trying.

Check Price

Coffee Piña Colada Cocktail

Wray and Nephew Rum

If you're looking for a white rum that's perfect for making a delicious Pina Colada, we highly recommend Wray & Nephew Overproof Rum. It's a versatile rum that's great for mixing and has a natural fruity aroma that will add depth to your cocktails.

Pros

• Best for mixing
• Natural fruity aroma
• High alcohol content

Cons

• Not suitable for diabetics
• Strong taste may not be for everyone
• May be too strong for some cocktails

Wray & Nephew Overproof Rum is perfect for Pina Coladas because it's a high-proof rum that can stand up to the sweet, creamy flavors of the coconut and pineapple. It has a natural fruity aroma that will add depth and complexity to your cocktail, making it taste even better.

When it comes to mixing, Wray & Nephew Overproof Rum is one of the best white rums out there. It has a high alcohol content of 63% vol. that will give your cocktails a kick. It's also versatile enough to be used in a variety of other cocktails, such as the Jamaican Wray and Ting or the Reggae Rum Punch.

However, it's important to note that Wray & Nephew Overproof Rum is not suitable for diabetics due to its high sugar content. Additionally, its strong taste may not be for everyone, and it may be too strong for some cocktails. But if you're looking for a white rum that's perfect for mixing and has a natural fruity aroma, Wray & Nephew Overproof Rum is definitely worth trying.

Check Price

Ginger-peach Piña Colada Cocktail

Facundo Neo White Rum

If you're looking for a high-quality white rum that can take your cocktails to the next level, Facundo Neo is a great choice.

Pros

• The blend of light and medium-bodied rums creates a unique flavor profile that's perfect for creative cocktails.
• The charcoal filtration process gives the rum a smooth, complex taste that's hard to find in other white rums.
• The stylish packaging and attractive gift box make Facundo Neo an excellent choice for a special occasion or gift.

Cons

• At a higher price point, Facundo Neo may not be the best choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
• The complex flavor profile may not be to everyone's taste, especially those who prefer a more straightforward white rum.
• While Facundo Neo is an excellent choice for cocktails, it may not be the best option for sipping neat or on the rocks.

Facundo Neo is an excellent choice for cocktails, especially those with a tropical flair like the classic pina colada. The blend of light and medium-bodied rums creates a unique flavor profile that's perfect for adding depth and complexity to your drinks. The charcoal filtration process also gives the rum a smooth, sophisticated taste that pairs well with the sweet, fruity flavors of a pina colada.

In addition to its excellent taste, Facundo Neo also comes in an attractive gift box that makes it a great choice for a special occasion or gift. The stylish packaging and high-quality rum inside make it a standout choice for anyone who appreciates the finer things in life.

Overall, we highly recommend Facundo Neo for anyone looking for a high-quality white rum that can take their cocktails to the next level. Whether you're mixing up a classic pina colada or trying out a new creation, this rum is sure to impress.

Check Price

Koloa Rum White Rum

If you're looking for a white rum that's perfect for Pina Coladas, Koloa Rum White Rum is a great choice. This rum has a unique combination of flavors that can make your daiquiris taste better.

Pros

• The rum has a long-lasting finish that's perfect for cocktails.
• The vanilla and banana notes in the rum add a unique flavor to your daiquiris.
• The rum is perfect for making mojitos too.

Cons

• The rum is slightly more expensive than other white rums.
• The rum is only available in a 700ml bottle.
• The rum may not be available in all areas.

Koloa Rum has a smooth and creamy texture that's perfect for Pina Colada. The rum has a unique combination of flavors that include vanilla, banana, and nectar of honeysuckle. The finish of the rum is long-lasting, which makes it perfect for cocktails.

We found that the Koloa Rum was perfect for making Pina Colada. The vanilla and banana notes in the rum add a unique flavor to the cocktail that's hard to find in other white rums. The rum is also perfect for making mojitos too.

One of the downsides of the Koloa Rum is that it's slightly more expensive than other white rums. The rum is also only available in a 700ml bottle, so it may not be the best choice for those who don't drink rum often. Additionally, the rum may not be available in all areas.

Overall, if you're looking for a white rum that's perfect for Pina Colada, Koloa Rum is a great choice. The unique combination of flavors and the long-lasting finish make it perfect for cocktails.

Check Price

Buying Guide

When it comes to choosing the best white rum, there are a few key features to consider. Here are some things to keep in mind:

Quality

First and foremost, you want to choose a high-quality white rum. Look for a product that is made with care and attention to detail. A good rum should be smooth and flavorful, with a well-balanced taste that is not too harsh or too sweet.

Age

While some people may think that older is always better, this is not necessarily the case with white rum. In fact, many high-quality white rums are aged for only a short period of time, or not at all. Instead, focus on the flavor profile of the rum, rather than its age.

Origin

Different regions produce different types of white rum, each with their own unique flavor profiles and characteristics. For example, Caribbean rums tend to be sweeter and more full-bodied, while South American rums are often drier and more complex. Consider where the rum is from and what type of flavors and aromas it is likely to have.

Mixability

If you plan to use your white rum for cocktails, it's important to choose a product that is mixable and versatile. Look for a rum that works well in a variety of drinks, from classic mojitos to fruity pina coladas.

For those looking for the best white rum for a Pina Colada, it is important to choose a rum that is sweet and fruity, with notes of coconut and pineapple. A good white rum can help to enhance the flavors of this classic cocktail, making it even more delicious and refreshing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some top shelf white rum brands?

There are many top shelf white rum brands available in the market. Some of the most popular ones include Bacardi, Havana Club, and Mount Gay. These brands are known for their quality and smooth taste. They are perfect for sipping or mixing in cocktails.

What is the best white rum for Piña Colada?

When it comes to making a perfect Piña Colada, the choice of white rum is crucial. One of the best white rums for Piña Colada is Don Q Cristal. This rum is light-bodied and has a smooth taste that complements the flavors of pineapple and coconut in the cocktail. It is also affordable and easily available.

What is the difference between white rum and silver rum?

White rum and silver rum are often used interchangeably, but there is a slight difference between the two. White rum is generally unaged and has a clear color. Silver rum, on the other hand, can be aged for a short period of time and has a slightly golden color. However, the taste and flavor of both types of rum are similar.

What is the smoothest white rum?

The smoothest white rum is subjective and varies from person to person. However, some of the smoothest white rums available in the market include Ron del Barrilito Blanco, Flor de Caña 4 Extra Seco, and El Dorado 3 Year. These rums have a smooth taste and are perfect for sipping or mixing in cocktails.

Is Malibu considered a white rum?

Malibu is a flavored rum that is made with coconut extract and is not considered a white rum. It has a distinct flavor and is often used in tropical cocktails like Piña Colada. However, if you are looking for a traditional white rum, Malibu is not the best choice.

We hope these frequently asked questions have helped you understand more about white rum and its different types. Remember to choose the right white rum for your cocktail to enhance its flavor and taste.